Comments on Reut R. Cohen: Fort Hood Shooter May Have Exhibited Signs of Radi...

Dear B. Adam, Thanks for your essay. I have seen ...

2009-12-15T17:04:13.042-08:00

Dear B. Adam,

Thanks for your essay. I have seen it. Also, I'd like to reiterate that I noted in my post that the user named "NidalHasan" posted comments on the document. It is pretty clear that he merely commented on it. I'm not questioning your article, but the alleged statements made by the Fort Hood shooter commenting on the Scribd.com document.

I appreciate that you took the time to post a link to your essay here with the new updated section.

With best regards,
Reut R. Cohen

Dear Ms. Reut I wrote the paper on Martyrdom Oper...

2009-12-15T13:56:50.621-08:00

Dear Ms. Reut

I wrote the paper on Martyrdom Operations vs Suicide Bombing which Nidal Hasan commented upon.

Please refer to the full version of the paper, which includes a discussion of Nidal Hasan's comments and actions at Fort Hood, here:

quran.nu/essays/

Regards

Hi Reut, Great article! By now you already know ...

2009-11-06T12:04:31.040-08:00

Hi Reut,

Great article!

By now you already know that the shooter at Fort Hood shouted "Allahu Akbar" as he massacred his fellow soldiers. Statements from colleagues of Mr. Malik Nidal Hasan suggest that he was very sympathetic to jihadists. Here at Women Against Shariah we are in complete agreement with you. There is no way to argue that Malik Nidal Hasan killed people because of Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD). He had never been to Iraq or Afghanistan. Psychologists don't suffer from PTSD because their patients do.

Sincerely,
Your friends at Women Against Shariah

" Hasan's comments on the internet sparke...

2009-11-06T11:37:21.802-08:00

" Hasan's comments on the internet sparked the interest of federal law enforcement. "

" commented a user named "NidalHasan" "

That seems pretty clear to me. Reut my advice is not to post any more clarifications for anyone. Nothing you wrote is difficult to understand unless a person deliberately wants to misunderstand.

Thanks for your article Reut. The update is helpfu...

2009-11-06T11:28:55.200-08:00

Thanks for your article Reut. The update is helpful.

It is also concise and clear to me. Chill out people.

Hasan commented on a document on Scribd which come...

2009-11-06T11:15:28.642-08:00

Hasan commented on a document on Scribd which comes from another website (salafi-something). His comments appear under the article. That's exactly what Reut's article says. There needs to be no other explanations. Is it so hard to read and understand clear English?

The man is a fanatical monster. A major killing his own soldiers while screaming 'god is great' is disgusting.

Anonymous, If you look at the Scribd.com site, yo...

2009-11-06T11:07:13.215-08:00

Anonymous,

If you look at the Scribd.com site, you will clearly see that a user going by the name "Nidal Hasan" made comments on an article.

Click here to read the comments.

I never claimed a user called "Nidal Hasan" posted the article. I wrote that this person posted comments on an article. There is a big difference.

Therefore, there is no reason for any additional updates or clarification. The article is very clear as it is.

Best wishes,
Reut R. Cohen

Anonymous: I commend you for your stance against e...

2009-11-06T10:58:47.503-08:00

Anonymous: I commend you for your stance against extremism and terrorism, especially in light of threats and other abuse. I will read these documents and hope that people will recognize that plenty of Muslims do not stand for atrocities committed in their name.

Best wishes,
Reut R. Cohen

Furthermore, from scribd it seems that it was not ...

2009-11-06T10:56:28.989-08:00

Furthermore, from scribd it seems that it was not the poster with the name 'Nidal Hasan' who posted the article but rather someone called 'Riz Khan999' who posted it in opposition to the one with the name 'Nidal Hasan'. Hence, the article was posted to refute what was stated by 'Nidal Hasan'. This update also needs to be made to your article Reut.

Okay Reut, thanks for the update to your article! ...

2009-11-06T10:47:26.737-08:00

Okay Reut, thanks for the update to your article! Please refer to our website and please for your own record and see the articles that we have there which are totally against such acts of betrayal, extremism, terrorism and treachery:

www.salafimanhaj.com/pdf/SalafiManhaj_NYPD.pdf

www.salafimanhaj.com/pdf/SalafiManhaj_Terrorism_In_KSA.pdf

www.salafimanhaj.com/pdf/SalafiManhaj_AlQaidaIran

Not to mention a whole host of other details, for which we at the site have had death threats from terrorists and extremists.

Anonymous 2: I have added clarification. For the r...

2009-11-06T10:32:39.905-08:00

Anonymous 2: I have added clarification. For the record, I never stated anywhere that Hasan contributed to your website. This is a serious claim, without any merit, for you to make. I never used the shooter's name in conjunction with "contributor" anywhere.

Please see my update in the original blog post. I hope this resolves the issue you believe exists.

Regards,
Reut R. Cohen

Anonymous 1 (and other readers): Thanks for your e...

2009-11-06T10:23:55.725-08:00

Anonymous 1 (and other readers): Thanks for your email describing your technical issue with commenting. If you have any additional problems posting on my website, please let me know immediately.

Regards,
Reut R. Cohen

There is a serious error in this post, for it says...

2009-11-06T10:02:50.652-08:00

There is a serious error in this post, for it says that Nidal "posted praise of suicide bombers at salafimanhaj.com"!!!!!?

I am a contributor to that site and the website categorically had no contributions from him whatsoever!

Please check your sources thoroughly before making such serious claims and allegations.

Moreover, salafimanhaj.com has been consistently against suicide bombings. So it would be more accurate for you to have said that someone with the same name as him was discussing the issue and made referral to an article from the site - an article does not praise the likes of his actions.

Hasan did this because he is a Muslim fanatic. All...

2009-11-06T10:02:30.405-08:00

Hasan did this because he is a Muslim fanatic. All of the Muslims who are now complaining need to ask themselves how they would feel if their children was shot down by some religious nut. Taxpayers subsidized Hasan's schooling so he could murder fellows soldiers.

Hasan's relatives should realize they are not the only Americans who have felt persecuted. The difference is the rest of us minorities don't use that as an excuse to murder people we have political and religious disagreements with.

Islam = the religion of body pieces.